By Sanjay Dubey

The recent resignation of Tulsi Gabbard from her post as the Director of National Intelligence (DNI) marks a telling pattern. She is the fourth cabinet-level official to leave the Trump administration within a span of just three months. High turnover is hardly a novelty under Donald Trump; during his first presidential term, nearly 90 percent of his top-tier officials were replaced or ousted.
However, the striking anomaly this time lies in the demographics of departure. All four cabinet officials who have left the administration so far are women—a figure that represents exactly half of the total female representation in the Trump cabinet. While it is true that most of these women were surrounded by controversies and allegations, the same can easily be said about several male cabinet officials who continue to remain securely anchored in their positions.
This raises a fundamental question: Can we view these high-profile exits merely as routine administrative shifts or personal decisions? Or is there a deeper, systemic gender bias at play? If so, it invites us to examine a larger global reality: when it comes to institutional gender parity, are governing structures from New Delhi to Washington equally flawed?
India
In 2023, India passed the historic Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam (Women’s Reservation Act), aimed at securing a 33 percent quota for women in national parliament and state assemblies. The legislative triumph was widely celebrated, yet its actual implementation remains deferred to an uncertain future. The law was bound to two stringent preconditions: the reservation will only take effect after the next official census (scheduled post-2026) followed by a subsequent delimitation exercise to redraw constituency boundaries. Effectively, a structural right that could have been granted immediately was pushed into an indefinite timeline.
In stark contrast, Indian women secured grassroots reservation in local municipal and village bodies decades ago. India also historically made headlines by electing a woman Prime Minister, Indira Gandhi, less than twenty years after gaining independence. Yet, looking at the current federal structure, out of 30 cabinet ministers, only two are women—and one of them holds the traditionally gender-siloed Ministry of Women and Child Development. Furthermore, among the five Ministers of State with Independent Charge, there is not a single woman. Of the remaining 36 Ministers of State, only five are women, none of whom hold portfolios that could be classified as traditionally powerful or strategic.
Excluding Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, no female leader in the central cabinet wields the kind of institutional authority enjoyed by her male counterparts. Even in her case, political analysts frequently argue that the most critical financial decisions are steered directly by the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) rather than the ministry itself.
While Sitharaman also holds the distinction of having served as the nation’s Defence Minister, no other woman has ever headed the ministry responsible for the country’s borders. Similarly, internal security—the Ministry of Home Affairs—has never been entrusted to a woman, except when Indira Gandhi held it as an additional portfolio. When the late Sushma Swaraj was appointed as the first full-time female External Affairs Minister, it was an open secret that her administrative footprint resembled that of a junior minister. Major diplomatic breakthroughs were largely handled by Prime Minister Narendra Modi during his extensive foreign travels, with the PMO managing the rest.
The United States
Across the ocean, the United States routinely lectures the world on democracy and institutional equality. At the dawn of the second Trump administration, it briefly appeared that women were being handed the reins of some of the most formidable sectors of governance. However, by May 2026, that illusion completely shattered.
Tulsi Gabbard’s resignation as DNI is merely the latest link in a fast-developing chain. Before her, Attorney General Pam Bondi was removed from her post, Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem was dismissed, and Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer was shown the exit. In every single instance, the vacancies left by these women were promptly filled by men. Conversely, not a single male cabinet-level minister has been removed from his position, despite navigating massive public controversies. The male officials who were displaced were either peripheral advisors or lower-level staff.
Consider the case of Mike Waltz, Trump’s former national security adviser. After becoming embroiled in a major controversy, he was removed from his position but given another prestigious assignment as US ambassador to the United Nations. FBI Director Kash Patel offers another example. Despite facing repeated controversies and criticism, he remains firmly in his position. The contrast with the treatment of several female Cabinet officials is striking. While they lost their positions and were replaced by men, senior male officials facing serious criticism have either retained their jobs or, in Waltz’s case, been accommodated elsewhere in the administration.
Following Gabbard’s exit, her position is set to be filled by Aaron Lucas. This leaves women occupying just four out of the 26 cabinet-level positions in the US administration—a mere 15 percent. A closer look at these remaining portfolios reveals an even darker reality. Except for White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles, whose role remains central to any administration, the remaining female cabinet members manage severely diminished domains. Linda McMahon heads an Education Department that the administration actively intends to dismantle, while Brooke Rollins leads an Agriculture Department facing deep proposed budget cuts. Kelly Loeffler runs the Small Business Administration, a relatively minor agency.
When it comes to women’s representation, America’s two major parties have traditionally taken different approaches. Democrats have championed gender equality, with women holding a record 48 percent of Cabinet and Cabinet-level positions under Joe Biden, while Kamala Harris became the country’s first female vice president. Republicans, by contrast, have generally been more closely associated with traditional social values and male-dominated political leadership.
Yet, despite elevating women to some of the country’s most powerful positions, Democrats have been unable to break the highest glass ceiling in American politics. Both women they nominated for president—Hillary Clinton in 2016 and Kamala Harris in 2024—lost their elections. The United States, unlike many other democracies, has yet to elect a woman president.
It is a striking historical irony that South Asian countries such as India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka had women leading their governments decades ago—Indira Gandhi, Benazir Bhutto, Sheikh Hasina and Sirimavo Bandaranaike. Yet the United States, which prides itself on being a model of modern democracy, has never elected a woman to its highest office.
India, however, has its own contradiction. It has elected two women presidents—Pratibha Patil in 2007 and Droupadi Murmu in 2022—both of whom rose through grassroots politics. But in India’s parliamentary system, the prime minister holds the reins of government, and Indira Gandhi, who came from the country’s most powerful political dynasty, remains the only woman to have held that office.
Subscribe to get updates, bookmark, or comment.

